by Michael Ossipoff
The Occupy-Movement has conducted an internal poll, on political parties. It’s a good idea, but we’re now conducting a poll specifically about party platforms. That’s because the platforms themselves, what the parties actually offer, are the crucially relevant factor, for choice among the political parties. For that reason, our poll is announced as a poll on party-platforms. To emphasize that, our ballot includes direct links to the platforms.
We request that you read, or look at, at least one or a few of the platforms, including at least one or two of the non-Republocrat platforms. Of course, in the case of the Republocrats (Republicans and Democrats), their actions in office probably speak more loudly than their platforms. Because a long list of parties could make it prohibitively time-consuming to read platforms, we’re only including four platforms in our poll: Democrat, Republican, Green (GPUS), and Libertarian.
We’re conducting a rank balloting (rank the platforms in order of preference), in the comments section below. The rank balloting will be counted by Symmetrical ICT, a method that arguably best avoids strategic need to rank other than sincerely. Voting instructions is below:
To vote in the rank-balloting poll on party-platforms, here is what you’d do:
1. Go to the “comments” section at the bottom of this page.
2. Register if necessary. Click to “reply” to our “comment” that has the voting instructions.
3. Vote as described in the voting instructions given in our “comment”.
Read the platforms that are linked to below from the list of party platforms. Because, unlike the Democrats and Republicans, the Greens and Libertarians don’t have a (good or bad) track record, it’s particularly important to look at their platforms. Looking at platforms is crucial to finding out what is offered by parties. Here are links to the party platforms in the order they were presented in Google Search:
- The Republican Party Platform
- The Democratic Party Platform
- The Libertarian Party Platform
- The Green Party of the United States Platform
Judge for yourself whether the Democrats’ and Republicans’ track records are good or bad, in comparison to the platform proposals of the Greens and Libertarians. You can rank as many or as few platforms as many platforms as you want to.
You’re free to rank as many as you want at any rank position, though, to find the most popular platform, it would be best to rank them all in sincere order of preference. In particular, of course you ran rank as many platforms in first place as you want to. So, if you felt that it were necessary to rank a compromise in first place, you’d still be able to rank your favorite in first place too.
With our count method, Symmetrical ICT, you have no reason to not rank your favorite in 1st place. Though you can rank as many platforms as you want to, with out count method you have no strategic reason or need to rank any unacceptable candidates. Your ranking will fully count against any candidates whom you don’t rank.
So to sum up: Reply to this “comment”, by clicking “Reply” below. Then, in your comment-space, rank as many platforms as you want to, by writing them in a vertical, numbered list.
For instance:
- [Your favorite platform goes here]
- [Your 2nd favorite platform goes here]
- [Your 3rd favorite platform goes here]
- [Your last choice goes here]
Enjoy!
Adrian Tawfik says
1. Green Party
2. Democratic Party
3. Libertarian Party
4. Republican Party
Anonymous says
My ranking of the party platforms:
1. Green Party
——————-
I’m not ranking any other parties, because I regard the Green party’s policies to be the only acceptabe ones among our lineup.
With our count-rule, Symmetrical ICT, not ranking, or bottom-ranking, a particular set of alternatives counts as rankng each member of that unranked set below _everything_ else.
In Symmetrical ICT, a ballot that votes only two rank positions (1st rank, and unranked) is equivalent to an Approval ballot, in the sense that it maximally and fully votes for the 1st ranked alternative, and maximally and fully votes against the unranked alternatives.
Anonymous says
I neglected to sign my ballot. Ballots in this poll can be anonymous, but I intended to sign mine. The 2nd ranking in this election is mine–the one that ranked only the Green party.
Michael Ossipoff
Sarah says
1. Green Party
Jan says
1. Green Party
William Waugh says
Do you allow write-ins?
1. Justice Party
2. Green Party
William Waugh
Michael Ossipoff says
Yes. I’m certain that Adrian will agree with me that write-ins should be allowed.
Michael Ossipoff.
Adrian Tawfik says
Of course! Let the Justice Party join the fun!
Michael Ossipoff says
Though the front-page Approval poll is doing well, we don’t seem to be getting any more voters in this comment-space rank-balloting poll. The rankings were to be counted by Symmetrical ICT. Counting by that method, the Green party wins.
In fact the Green party is a very big winner in this poll. The Greens are the “Condorcet winner” (abbreviated “CW”). That means that, when compared to any other party, more people rank the Greens over that other party than vice-versa.
That means that the Greens would have won no matter what Condorcet method we’d used. That inludes Beatpath, or Condorcet-IRV.
But though this poll is no longer shown on the front-page, you csn still add your ranking.
But the Approval poll is still displayed at the front-page, and the polling is still going on. So, especially, vote in the front-page Approval poll on political parties, if you haven’t yet done so.
The Approval poll can be found in the right margin of the front-page, some distance down from the top.
Michael Ossipoff