• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • AMERICAN DEMOCRACY
  • WORLD DEMOCRACY
  • POLITICAL ART
  • more
    • election technology
    • money politics
    • political dissidents
    • THIRD PARTY
      • third party central
      • green party
      • justice party
      • libertarian party
    • voting methods
  • DC INFO
    • author central
    • about
    • advertise with DC
    • contact
    • privacy policy

Democracy Chronicles

On The Dynamics of Abortion. And Argentina.

By David Anderson, J.D. - January 19, 2021 Leave a Comment

FacebookTweetLinkedInPinShare1
Dynamics of Abortion
Coat of arms of Argentina – Image source

There’s big news from Argentina lately. By a fair margin (38 to 29) abortion was finally legalized there last month after many years of fighting and decades of grassroots activism.

Culturally, Argentina holds a lot of sway in Latin America in the same way the US does in the Anglosphere. A similar legalization effort failed two years ago (see my original article here). This new, finally successful bill was loudly opposed by supposedly “liberal” Argentine Pope Francis as well as the entirety of the inter-galactic Catholic Church, naturally. 

Festively, the battle was “colorized” in large demonstrations with the pro-women camp wearing green clothes and accoutrements and the regressive cross worshippers wearing blue. Both marched in huge numbers all amid an economic meltdown atop a terrible pandemic, neither of which are going well.

As usual, Argentina is years behind its tiny neighbor Uruguay, a progressive superpower where gay marriage, abortion, transsexual rights and even marijuana were all normalized a few years ago. But Argentina is ahead of most of Latin America now with the exception of Cuba and some Mexican states. Brazil’s “Trump of the Tropics” President Bolsonaro has already ruled out any changes to their “pro-life” set-up.

Apart from a few fanatical Catholic theocracies (lookin’ at you El Salvador, Honduras, the Philippines) most of humanity looks at our American abortion culture wars as if we’re in a mental hospital and they’re tourists there. Much of Latin America however, an area infected with both zika and Catholicism is a laggard regarding sexual rights. Argentina’s latest is commendable but still a baby step – pardon the pun. Abortion is only legal for up to 14 weeks there in normal circumstances even now. 

Like comedy, with abortion timing is everything. Because humans develop on a spectrum from a microscopic smudge to an actual “baby” where one draws the line of what is “human” or “alive” is open to some moral (but not medical) debate. 

Many people don’t know where that line is drawn but then many people don’t wear masks in pandemics and can’t work a condom to save their lives – or avoid creating a new one. I’m here all year folks, get your tickets at the door.

The actual line, the most scientific line is a hard 28 weeks. That’s post-viability but “viability” is a matter of geography/place only. “Why then, why 28 weeks?” – one might ask. Twenty-eight weeks is when there are reverberating, detectable chemical-electrical signals between the thalamus and the cortex in the fetal brain. That’s technical for sure but if you think of the thalamus as the seat of emotion and the cortex (at front of the head) as the computer, reverberating signals between the two equate to… thought. They equate to sentience which is the sense one is alive, a capacity to feel pain, perceive or experience things subjectively.

Before that, the item in the womb looks human and even has reflexes (like a knee when tapped, it can flinch, etc.) but by no standard according to the latest science is it capable of thought or pain. 

Until week 28 it functionally resembles the wooden frame of a home: half-built with no walls, lights, or electricity so it has all the “humanity” of a wisdom tooth, an appendix, a husk. This is irrespective of the value placed on it by the parents who might invest hope in it but hope does not a “human” make.

Pro-lifers armed with plastic fetuses and guns yelling outside clinics aren’t usually schooled in embryology and further, their organizations shamelessly lie to them about the actual scientific facts of prenatal development with dishonesty that is shocking: they’re almost giving out social security numbers to individual spermatozoa. They also neglect to admit that legal abortion is statistically safer for the mother than carrying a pregnancy to term.

Be that as it may, they’re not really protesting to “Save the babes” anyway – or they’d be pro-contraception. They’re not. Being anti-contraception and abortion at the same time is like trying to prevent fires by eliminating fire extinguishers and banning umbrellas to stop the rain. 

Their real motivation, whether they know it or not is to oppose promiscuity, to enforce a cost, and attach the terrible punishment of enforced pregnancy to it. It is hard to find a worse punishment than forcing women to birth as many babies as she doesn’t want. Mission Accomplished, Jesus!

They want the punishment for “lose” (but often enjoyable and entertaining) sex to be a permanent souvenir in the form of a new human or at least the threat of it.

So why do they hate promiscuity? Their respective motivations depend partly on gender. The women of that coalition hate promiscuity because, like pornography and prostitution which they also despise, it represents competition. 

What about the men? You’d think, given the wandering eye of the average dude promiscuity might seem like not a bad idea. But no because promiscuity equates to and can cause cuckoldry – “their” women being impregnated by other, higher-ranking men which is, evolutionary speaking, a costly dead end.

Finally, many hate promiscuity out of spite. Those red-faced, obese screamers outside women’s clinics: do you think they’re “gettin’ any”? You can be the judge of that but keep in mind the religious mindset (and religion is the main justification of course) abhors anybody having any pleasure, particularly sexual pleasure. So, yes: spite. 

With 65 deaths a year and 40,000 women hospitalized due to illegal abortions in the past few years one hopes Argentina’s sanity will be contagious to other parts of a continent – including some of our own states – which are also blighted by Christianity. A thought to ponder is that prior to modern, safe chemical and surgical abortion women used to commit infanticide at a similar rate as abortion today (Pinker, et al, 2011): between 10-50% of births. 

 –

David Anderson is not in the “Human Reproduction Business” but rather a lawyer living in NYC with his atheist dog. Voluntarily childless and Australian-American all at the same time he supports progressive causes and writes for various publications.

FacebookTweetLinkedInPinShare1

Filed Under: DC Authors Tagged With: Religion and Democracy, South America, Women and Democracy, Women Voting Rights

About David Anderson, J.D.

David Anderson is an Australian-American lawyer in NYC with an education in (Middle East) politics and psychology and a career background in finance and law. He was recently amusingly featured on Professor Jerry Coyne’s blog “Why Evolution is True” which can be viewed here.

Some highlighted Democracy Chronicles topics

Africa American Corruption American Local Elections American State Elections Asia Capitalism and Big Business Celebrity Politics China Democracy Charity Democracy Protests Democrats Dictatorships Education Election History Election Methods Election Security Election Transparency Europe Internet and Democracy Journalism and Free Speech Middle East Minority Voting Rights Money Politics New York City and State Elections Political Artwork Political Dissidents Political Lobbying Redistricting Republicans Russia Socialism and Labor Social Media and Democracy South America Spying and Privacy Supreme Court Third Party Voter Access Voter ID Voter Registration Voter Suppression Voter Turnout Voting Technology Women Voting Rights Worldwide Worldwide Corruption

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Home | DC AUTHORS | On The Dynamics of Abortion. And Argentina.

Primary Sidebar

Advertise button

There Won’t be Another Chance to Hold Biden’s Feet to the Fire

By Jack Jones

If we want to live in a somewhat decent country we must start to hold our president’s feet to the fire. We just can’t go along and complain.

Podcast: Anne Applebaum On Why Democracy Is Not Inevitable

By Jenna Spinelle

Journalist, author, and historian Anne Applebaum says that democracy is not like running water — something that we know will always be there.

democracy chronicles newsletter

DC AUTHORS

On the Attitudes of Our Leaders

By Jack Jones

Donald Trump Jr. standing in front of a wall of handguns with scopes is a clear threat that should not be tolerated.

Cruz Flies to Mexico While Abbott Spreads False Information

By Steve Schneider

Where were Texas leaders when an Arctic chill spread across Texas, depriving power to millions? Senator Ted Cruz got on a plane for Mexico.

I made it to 77

By Julio César Guerrero

We learned a lot from him. Perhaps the best lesson was that while there is life there is hope. Constantino Coronel inspires new generations of activists.

Parkland School Shooting Widow Speaks About Rep. Greene

By Steve Schneider

Sunday is the 3rd anniversary of the Parkland school shooting. Debbi Hixon who lost her husband Chris in the shooting speaks about Rep. Greene.

Trickling Down to Right-Wing Fascism

By Jack Jones

The Rich and greedy have always wanted more and they won’t stop. That’s why they hate it when we regulate anything for the good of the country.

Court Rules Therapists Have Right to Offer Conversion Therapy

By Steve Schneider

A three-judge federal panel recently green-lighted a controversial form of treatment for minors despite opposition.

How Do Farm and Rural Communities Vote?

By Hrvoje Milakovic

The popular belief is that farmers in rural areas believe that the Republicans and their conservative beliefs are more likely to help their communities.

MORE FROM OUR AUTHORS

VISIT OUR POLITICAL ART SECTION:

dc political art

DEMOCRACY CULTURE

Rapper Common To Produce Biopic On Voting Activist Fannie Lou Hamer

Rapper Common To Produce Biopic On Voting Activist Fannie Lou Hamer

Lonnie Rashid Lynn, who is known by his stage name Common is set to produce a biopic on civil rights activist Fannie Lou Hamer.

Study: Nature’s Power To Awe Might Reduce Political Polarization

Study: Nature’s Power To Awe Might Reduce Political Polarization

According to new findings in psychology, by using nature’s scenes to induce a sense of awe we can reduce political polarization.

Formula 1's Lewis Hamilton Stand for Saudi Rights

Will Formula 1’s Lewis Hamilton Stand for Saudi Rights?

Lewis Hamilton asked to reconsider participation in the upcoming race being hosted in Saudi Arabia in 2021.

4 Ways You Can Help Combat Exploitation Through Your Shopping

4 Ways You Can Help Combat Exploitation Through Your Shopping

Everyday products like sugar, coffee, chocolate, are at high risk of having slavery in their supply chain. There are 4 ways you can fight this.

MORE CULTURE

VISIT OUR US DEMOCRACY SECTION:

American Democracy