• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Democracy Chronicles

Towards better democracy everywhere.

  • AMERICAN DEMOCRACY
  • WORLD DEMOCRACY
  • POLITICAL ART
  • more
    • election technology
    • money politics
    • political dissidents
    • THIRD PARTY
      • third party central
      • green party
      • justice party
      • libertarian party
    • voting methods
  • DC INFO
    • author central
    • about
    • advertise with DC
    • contact
    • privacy policy
You are here: Home / American Democracy Originals / INTERVIEW: Redistricting, Vote Splitting and Honest Voting

INTERVIEW: Redistricting, Vote Splitting and Honest Voting

May 31, 2012 by Adrian Tawfik Leave a Comment

FacebookLinkedInPinTweet

Vote Splitting and Honest Voting Strategies

Election-Method Expert Discusses Election Methodology Theory, the Possibilities For Serious Reform in America, Vote Splitting and Honest Voting Strategies

In continuation of Democracy Chronicles’ series of interviews with prominent members involved with “The Declaration of Election-Method Reform Advocates“, we now turn to Andrew Jennings, Chief Financial Officer and a member of the Board of Directors of the Center for Election Science.  Mr. Jennings is a resident of Mesa, Arizona.

In the “About Us” section of the Center for Election Science website, Mr. Jennings is described as follows:

“Andy was born and raised in Mesa, Arizona. He did his undergraduate work in mathematics at Arizona State University. Andy continued at Arizona State when in 2010 he completed his Ph.D. in mathematics. Given his strong interest in voting theory, Andy did his dissertation on the concepts of monotonicity and gaming in both ordinal- and cardinal-class voting systems.  Andy continues to live near his roots in Mesa, Arizona. He is also the founder of Shoptivate.com, a software company that sells search solutions for e-commerce sites.”

Mr. Jennings discusses election reform in the United States as well as voting methodology.


Democracy Chronicles founder Adrian Tawfik conducted an exclusive interview series with an international group of election method proponents including prominent signers of the Declaration of Election-Method Reform Advocates. The best place to start off is the Democracy Chronicles introduction and then take a look at each of these interviews:

  • Richard Fobes – Election Method Reformer Speaks With DC 
  • Aaron Hamlin – Interview With President of Center for Election Science
  • Andrew Jennings – Redistricting, Vote Splitting and Honest Voting
  • augustin – Writer Discusses Election Reform and New Website
  • Michael Allen – Election Method Reformer Seeks Radical Changes 
  • Jameson Quinn – Election Expert Discusses Reform in US and Guatemala
  • Michael Ossipoff – Democracy Chronicles Author Discusses Approval Voting
  • Robert Bristow-Johnson – Expert Demands Reducing Money in Elections

Also see the DC Interview With Creator of Wooden Models of Voting Methods with artist Peter A. Taylor. 

Interview with Andrew Jennings:

Democracy Chronicles: What characteristics do you think are most important for a voting method to have? How does it deal with Vote Splitting and Honest Voting?

The process should allow many good candidates to run without splitting the vote and the voting process should match up pretty well with the thought process voters use to evaluate the candidates.

Never require voters to betray favorites.  If I think John Doe is the absolute best candidate in the world to for US president, then usually John Doe isn’t in the race.  But if he were, even as a third-party candidate or an independent and he had no chance of winning, I should be able to rank him first or give him the highest grade without compromising my voice among the other contenders.

It should allow, even encourage, honest voting, if possible.  Voting is so much easier if you don’t have to worry about being strategic, and society is much happier if people don’t feel like their opponents cheated to win.  Candidates should come out of the election with a societal grade, so they really know whether they have a mandate, and so everyone feels like their vote counts by having some effect on the final scores, however small.

Democracy Chronicles: What do you think is the most important election reform needed where you live (either locally or nationally)?  Why is this reform important?

Both locally and nationally, we need a system that allows many good candidates to run.  One that doesn’t encourage politics of fear.

Democracy Chronicles: What is your opinion on other aspects of election reform such as reforming money’s role in politics or redistricting?

I wish there were some way to reform money’s role in politics, but I’m afraid it’s impossible.   Politicians have power and money naturally flows downhill toward power.  Whatever roadblocks we establish for businesses trying to influence politicians, the money will find a way around them.  I think the only answer is to try to decrease the power of big government and bring all important decisions back to the local level.  Unfortunately, government power and responsibility is much easier to ratchet up than to ratchet down.

On Vote Splitting and Redistricting

As for redistricting, for a jurisdiction with two legislative bodies, like the United States or Arizona, I think one body should be elected with a proportional voting system that ignores geography.  The other body can use districting, but it should be done by computer (with an algorithm like shortest splitline) or with a public contest and a predefined rule (anyone can submit maps and the one with the lowest total perimeter wins).  We should minimize or eliminate all human judgment in the redistricting process.  A non-partisan committee is not good enough.

FacebookLinkedInPinTweet

Filed Under: American Democracy Originals Tagged With: Election Methods, Redistricting

Some highlighted Democracy Chronicles topics

Africa American Corruption American Local Elections American State Elections Asia Capitalism and Big Business Celebrity Politics China Democracy Charity Democracy Protests Democrats Dictatorships Education Election History Election Methods Election Security Election Transparency Europe Internet and Democracy Journalism and Free Speech Middle East Minority Voting Rights Money Politics New York City and State Elections Political Artwork Political Dissidents Political Lobbying Redistricting Republicans Russia Socialism and Labor Social Media and Democracy South America Spying and Privacy Supreme Court Third Party Voter Access Voter ID Voter Registration Voter Suppression Voter Turnout Voting Technology Women Voting Rights Worldwide Worldwide Corruption

About Adrian Tawfik

Democracy Chronicles has been run by Founder and Editor-in-Chief Adrian Tawfik since 2011. He received a B.A. from New School University and is based in New York City where he built DC from the ground up. See Adrian's Opinion Column for a sampling of Adrian's personal views and browse his hundreds of original political memes. Also take a look at the rest of our international team of authors.

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

democracy chronicles newsletter

DC Authors

Heartbreak and Yearning on the Streets of East Oakland

May 19, 2023 By Joe Mathews

“Nightcrawling” by Leila Mottley is a bestselling novel that explores the hardships of life in Oakland’s struggling streets.

Podcast: Gen Z’s Fight For Democracy

May 18, 2023 By Jenna Spinelle

In his book “Fight”, John Della Volpe argues that Gen Z has not buckled under the weight of the events that shaped them.

Advertise button

Courts, Constitutions, & Democracy: A Failing System

April 29, 2023 By Andrew Straw

Equal protection on its face means that everyone is treated equally but the U.S. Supreme Court has limited equal protection.

Newsom’s ‘Campaign For Democracy’ Has A Democracy Problem

April 26, 2023 By Joe Mathews

The governor has sympathies for changes in governance; he’s deeply familiar with democratic innovation. But will he actually take on democratic reform?

Podcast: Between Democracy And Autocracy

April 19, 2023 By Jenna Spinelle

Between democracy and autocracy is an anocracy, defined by political scientists as a country that has elements of both forms of government.

Who Will Protect The Global Economy From California?

April 18, 2023 By Joe Mathews

This bank failure, the second largest in U.S. history, actually fits a very old pattern—of California and its industries putting the economies of the nation and the world at risk.

Split Level In Jersey

April 15, 2023 By Jamie Lampidis

Everyone has limits to their goodness, Like those structures in her oil paintings, Cartoonishly stretched to contain something within.

California, Keep Your Schools Open. No Matter What

April 14, 2023 By Joe Mathews

California’s school reopening revealed education disparities, highlighting the need to rebuild trust and relationships for addressing these inequalities.

More DC author posts

Democracy Culture

Using Beer As Reminder Of UK Voting Rule Change

Using Beer As Reminder Of UK Voting Rule Change

May 7, 2023

Brixton Brewery has launched a beer can campaign to encourage voters in the UK to bring their photo ID to vote.

Macron Honors Haitian Revolutionary, But Leaves Much Unsaid

Macron Honors Haitian Revolutionary, But Leaves Much Unsaid

May 2, 2023

Macron visited the prison where Toussaint Louverture died, praising him as a hero who embodied French Revolution values.

Iranian Secret Committee 'Punished Celebrities Over Dissent'

Iranian Secret Committee ‘Punished Celebrities Over Dissent’

April 28, 2023

Iran’s Secret committee sent a list of 141 to the economy ministry, including celebrities, raising more worries over freedoms.

Rewards Get People To See Truth In Politically Unfavorable Info

Rewards Get People To See Truth In Politically Unfavorable Info

March 30, 2023

People don’t carefully evaluate links for accuracy and that partisanship may be secondary to the rush of getting a lot of likes on social media.

Pussy Riot Will Receive This Year's Woody Guthrie Prize

Pussy Riot Will Receive This Year’s Woody Guthrie Prize

March 30, 2023

Russian performance collective Pussy Riot will receive this year’s Woody Guthrie prize honoring art for social change, award organizers said Thursday.

More Democracy Culture posts