• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • AMERICAN DEMOCRACY
  • WORLD DEMOCRACY
  • POLITICAL ART
  • more
    • election technology
    • money politics
    • political dissidents
    • THIRD PARTY
      • third party central
      • green party
      • justice party
      • libertarian party
    • voting methods
  • DC INFO
    • author central
    • about
    • contact
    • privacy policy

Democracy Chronicles

New York State and the World’s Oldest Profession

By David Anderson, J.D. - March 17, 2020 1 Comment

FacebookTweetLinkedInPinShare1
New York State and the World’s Oldest Profession
Image by Gerd Altmann from Pixabay

As a defense attorney practicing in the courtrooms of Queens and Manhattan some years ago, a few of my clients were prostitutes who were busted for doing their job.

It occurred to me while bargaining their sentences down to little jail time: What an absurd machine I’ve been caught up in. It was the same feeling I got defending drug “criminals” in Drug Court.

The injustice of prostitutes being criminally charged may change soon as the state of New York is preparing – quietly and after an interminable wait – to decriminalize prostitution. New York’s prospective law:

“would allow paid sex between consenting adults — decriminalizing both the buying and the selling of sex, as well as promotion of prostitution — while maintaining prohibitions on trafficking, coercion and sexual abuse of minors.” –  New York Times.

This would be a huge improvement in the current state of affairs because: and take time with this sentence – not only can we not effectively legislate morality but trying to, causes more harm than good.

In his well-regarded legal studies, Professor Tom Tyler (Yale) found that prohibition of drugs (and we can assume prostitution) only dissuades five percent of people from indulging in a vice. This means the entire joint edifice of the war on drugs and the war on women only dissuades a small number of people. That represents an incredible price – when you toll it up next to the costs – for a vanishingly slim payoff. The data didn’t apply specifically to prostitution but we can make a guess that the dynamics of personal choice, the risk-reward calculation, is similar to that “vice” also.

There’s always the argument: “Well if you legalize it (heroin, prostitution, gambling, etc.) everybody will do it.” The response to which is: “Would you?”  – or – “Would anybody you know?”   At that question, the prohibitionist usually wilts.

Harm reduction works: it’s that simple. But there are some bumps on the legislative road before the world’s oldest profession is legitimized in America’s most progressive state.

The first goes very deeply into the psychology of humans. Like anti-abortionists (“pro-lifers”, as if a woman’s control of her body is somehow “pro-death”), anti-prostitution activists are not trying to punish sex for money. When the price isn’t an issue it is called dating or marriage. But deep in our lizard brains, we all have a dog in the fight against promiscuity.

They are evolutionary reasons for this which differ for each gender. For men its cuckoldry: prostitution is opposed by some men for the same reason legalized abortion is – it is seen as encouraging promiscuity which is taken as an entrée to cuckoldry. That is the motivation, psychologically speaking, even if the prohibitionists don’t realize it themselves. For men promiscuity can be a disaster because it can lead to cuckoldry and from an evolutionary biology standpoint (involuntarily) raising another man’s child is a genetic dead end and to be avoided at all costs.

For women, promiscuity is a threat also because, well, its competition. It’s why “pro-lifers” also condemn contraception as well as abortion – because again their goal is not to “save the babes” – it’s to stop people screwing.
Further, given that pscho-dynamic undergirding, another motivation for the prohibitionist is sheer spite: just look at the (usually male) old, obese, red-faced shouters outside abortion clinics or those standing up against legalized prostitution: those men aren’t getting any “action” anytime soon. Never underestimate spite in human motivation. Again – this is often unbeknownst to the person as a lot of our motivations are sub-rational.

What would legalization and legitimization mean for the prostitute “victims”? For a start, they wouldn’t be branded criminals with that stain pursuing their life and career forever. It would mean they’re not sent to jail where they would otherwise fall into company with better criminals at Jail University.

They’d have an OSHA regulated workplace regarding hygiene and safety, help from the police in the case of “disagreeable” (violent, murderous) customers, legal rights, better treatment by and access to the health care community and thus better medical care.

And hopefully, they’d win a place in society that is less victimized by the scorn of religious fanatics and moral purists from both right and left.

We don’t even need to experiment when it comes to Harm Reduction – just look at the data: the regulated, controlled prostitution laws of northern Europe and Australia have reduced human trafficking significantly and with it much of the stigma. Legalized prostitution works.

In Sydney, Australia, there are several large, legal brothels – “Four floors of whores!” goes the off-color joke – and they’re run according to strict government regulations. The same is true in Northern Europe, Brazil, Turkey and parts of the developing world including two counties in Nevada.

A threat to New York State and the pressure group decrim.org’s efforts exists though: the recent trend on the left of categorizing all prostitution as “sex trafficking”. The logic, by some feminists and Christians, goes as follows –

– I wouldn’t be a sex worker
– Other people wouldn’t (because I wouldn’t and I’m right), so by definition prostitutes must be coerced.
– That means all prostitutes are trafficked.

What a terrible argument! For a start, they’re not.

Secondly, while surely no little girl on her 10th birthday says she wants to grow up and be a hooker, equally few say they want to grow up and be a shelf stocker at Walmart or eviscerate chickens at a meat freezing works. People make trade-offs and choices as options present themselves and for some women sex for money is a rational, considered payoff.

The categorizing of all prostitutes as trafficked sex slaves works against the very best thing which protects them: legalization, legitimization, and regulation. Like New York State is trying to do – ever so quietly.

The women I defended in court were marginal people – forced into a job few would prefer but some do choose, as many of us take less than optimal paths in life. The State, pushed by people blessed with better life circumstances,
decided these marginal women need to be punished by prohibition. Let’s end this madness.

Australian-American writer David Anderson formerly practiced criminal defense law in the courtrooms of Manhattan and Queens.

FacebookTweetLinkedInPinShare1

Filed Under: DC Authors Tagged With: American Corruption, Democracy Protests, Women and Democracy

About David Anderson, J.D.

David Anderson is an Australian-American lawyer in NYC with an education in (Middle East) politics and psychology and a career background in finance and law. He was recently amusingly featured on Professor Jerry Coyne’s blog “Why Evolution is True” which can be viewed here.

Some highlighted Democracy Chronicles topics

Africa American Corruption American Local Elections American State Elections Asia Capitalism and Big Business Celebrity Politics China Democracy Charity Democracy Protests Democrats Dictatorships Education Election History Election Methods Election Security Election Transparency Europe Internet and Democracy Journalism and Free Speech Middle East Minority Voting Rights Money Politics New York City and State Elections Political Artwork Political Dissidents Political Lobbying Redistricting Republicans Russia Socialism and Labor Social Media and Democracy South America Spying and Privacy Supreme Court Syria Third Party Voter Access Voter ID Voter Registration Voter Turnout Voting Technology Women Voting Rights Worldwide Worldwide Corruption

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Jack Jones says

    March 24, 2020 at 11:07 pm

    You always have great things to share! The uphill battle for common sense seems to be a unwinnable especially with the same forces being pulled deeper in the mire by Trump himself! There always seems to be a fool trying to pull us off course! I’m glad to see people like you trying to lift people to a vantage point of clarity! Great article, good work! Jack

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Home | DC AUTHORS | New York State and the World’s Oldest Profession

Primary Sidebar

donate button

America After Trump

By Jenny Oak Tree

Our country must grieve and we must understand the trauma that has been created by Trumpism. Only then can the United States rise again.

Teaching Voting Theory With a Card-Based Voting Game

By Steve Cobb

This uniquely inventive new game’s name ‘Concurrence’ is a play on words: it means “agreement” in English and “competition” in Russian.

democracy chronicles newsletter

DC AUTHORS

U

By Aydasara Ortega

Data governance surfaces as key terrain on which to regulate firms engaged in datafication by responding to the injustices of informational capitalism.

On The Dynamics of Abortion. And Argentina.

By David Anderson, J.D.

There’s big news from Argentina lately. By a fair margin abortion was finally legalized there last month after decades of grassroots activism.

An Expat American in the Middle East Discusses Trump Concerns

By Steve Schneider

Democracy Chronicles author Steve Schneider interviews ex-pat American Jason Meursault who shares his overseas perspective on the Capitol riot.

Why Trump Should be Impeached

By Jack Jones

Trump’s tenure was a reign of terror. The 6 Jan insurrection is ground for Senate impeachment to prevent him from causing further damage to our democracy.

On Approval Voting and the National Popular Vote

By Steve Cobb

Though written without regard for alternative voting methods, maybe the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact is OK.

Is Giuliani a Speech-Maker or a Criminal Instigator?

By Steve Schneider

Rudy Giuliani is Trump’s personal lawyer. He has spoken in two rallies that became criminal riots, including the Jan 6, 2021, mob attack on The Capitol.

Democracy Counts in Georgia; D.C. in Chaos

By Steve Schneider

Major upheavals in American politics saw democrats winning Georgia on Jan 5, 2021 while on Jan 6 a Trump mob attacked The Capitol to stop certification of Biden’s victory.

MORE FROM OUR AUTHORS

VISIT OUR POLITICAL ART SECTION:

dc political art

DEMOCRACY CULTURE

Protest Art from Around the World

Foundation Publishes Protest Art from Around the World

Art has been a powerful medium of protest and creative expression to expose the deception and social bankruptcy of tyranny.

Protecting Californian Elections

How Bad Jokes Complicated Protecting Californian Elections

Public records show California’s scattershot cybersecurity approach ensnared some people who say they were joking.

Kanye West Kept Off the 2020 Arizona Ballot

Why Was Kanye West Kept Off the 2020 Arizona Ballot?

On September 8, the Arizona Supreme Court issued a short order saying Kanye West could not be on the ballot as an independent candidate for president.

Political Comedy Helps Young Adults

Study Claims Political Comedy Helps Young Adults

Interesting news on this front comes from the University of Pennsylvania: New research suggests that humor may

MORE CULTURE

VISIT OUR US DEMOCRACY SECTION:

American Democracy