• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Democracy Chronicles

Towards better democracy everywhere.

  • AMERICAN DEMOCRACY
  • WORLD DEMOCRACY
  • POLITICAL ART
  • more
    • election technology
    • money politics
    • political dissidents
    • THIRD PARTY
      • third party central
      • green party
      • justice party
      • libertarian party
    • voting methods
  • DC INFO
    • author central
    • about
    • advertise with DC
    • contact
    • privacy policy
You are here: Home / DC Authors / Thomas Paine Was Not A Libertarian

Thomas Paine Was Not A Libertarian

April 8, 2022 by Gary Berton Leave a Comment

FacebookLinkedInPinTweet

Libertarianism is anti-democratic because it attempts to negate “the association of the nation”, which is how Paine defined government. Libertarianism is the feeble step-child of anarchism: espousing that the individual is everything, the collective is always oppressive.

Anarchism denies the sociability of humans and the strength that it inures; instead, anarchism only sees individuals, alienated from each other, gaining no advantage from what Paine sees as the natural instincts of humans to form social bonds, and those bonds forming the basis for the national association of government.

In Paine’s view, it is government, and not its absence, that should be the enforcer of rights. To protect an individual’s rights can only be done collectively. All of Paine’s governmental proposals start with a constitution clearly defining rights. Government should not be a negative, but a positive force for human rights. In comparison to monarchy and mixed government, a simple, direct efficient government can only be attained by democratic representation and democratic implementation, according to Paine.

Libertarianism grew out of the philosophies of oligarchy. It follows from John Jay’s “the people who own the country should run the country” statement, and John Calhoun’s “I have the freedom to own slaves”. It is applied anarchy of restricting government, Reagan’s “government is the problem”, but putting the elite in charge at the same time: i.e., individualism should rule, collective goals are a denial of freedom. That is the mantra, leaving the wealthy as the only ones in a position to exert power.

This has real, modern impacts, mostly through well-funded think tanks of the rich, the Heritage Foundation, the Federalist Society, Cato Institute, and others. All founded in the 1970s to promote the ideologies of the previous paragraph. The architect was James Buchanan (not the President, the philosopher from the University of Chicago who implemented many racist economic policies – if you haven’t read MacLean’s Democracy in Chains you should). Buchanan was the ideologue behind these right-wing think tanks. He created the politburo of the right-wing structures, set up to deny democratic hopes. Libertarianism is their language.

This gets us back to the first principles of Paine: individuals can only achieve their rights collectively, otherwise only the rich can thrive. If everyone has equal rights protected by the government, that government must be democratic, and vice versa. Buchanan is the reverse of Paine. The wealthy should rule, the individual who is wealthy should rule.

Collectively, the wealthy are outnumbered, and one-person-one-vote makes them meaningless. How can they hang onto their obscene wealth like that?! When Buchanan was sent down to Chile in 1980 to write their constitution that was imposed on the people of Chile, he made wealth exempt from government regulation or even appropriate taxation.

So when Libertarians say they love Paine, they contradict themselves, or they haven’t read Paine.

FacebookLinkedInPinTweet

Filed Under: DC Authors Tagged With: Anarchism, Election History, Founding Fathers, Libertarian Party News, Thomas Paine

Some highlighted Democracy Chronicles topics

Africa American Corruption American Local Elections American State Elections Asia Capitalism and Big Business Celebrity Politics China Democracy Charity Democracy Protests Democrats Dictatorships Education Election History Election Methods Election Security Election Transparency Europe Internet and Democracy Journalism and Free Speech Middle East Minority Voting Rights Money Politics New York City and State Elections Political Artwork Political Dissidents Political Lobbying Redistricting Republicans Russia Socialism and Labor Social Media and Democracy South America Spying and Privacy Supreme Court Third Party Voter Access Voter ID Voter Registration Voter Suppression Voter Turnout Voting Technology Women Voting Rights Worldwide Worldwide Corruption

About Gary Berton

Gary Berton writes for DC from New York. He is President of the Thomas Paine National Historical Association and Associate Editor of the Collected Works of Thomas Paine Project.

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

democracy chronicles newsletter

DC Authors

Heartbreak and Yearning on the Streets of East Oakland

May 19, 2023 By Joe Mathews

“Nightcrawling” by Leila Mottley is a bestselling novel that explores the hardships of life in Oakland’s struggling streets.

Podcast: Gen Z’s Fight For Democracy

May 18, 2023 By Jenna Spinelle

In his book “Fight”, John Della Volpe argues that Gen Z has not buckled under the weight of the events that shaped them.

Advertise button

Courts, Constitutions, & Democracy: A Failing System

April 29, 2023 By Andrew Straw

Equal protection on its face means that everyone is treated equally but the U.S. Supreme Court has limited equal protection.

Newsom’s ‘Campaign For Democracy’ Has A Democracy Problem

April 26, 2023 By Joe Mathews

The governor has sympathies for changes in governance; he’s deeply familiar with democratic innovation. But will he actually take on democratic reform?

Podcast: Between Democracy And Autocracy

April 19, 2023 By Jenna Spinelle

Between democracy and autocracy is an anocracy, defined by political scientists as a country that has elements of both forms of government.

Who Will Protect The Global Economy From California?

April 18, 2023 By Joe Mathews

This bank failure, the second largest in U.S. history, actually fits a very old pattern—of California and its industries putting the economies of the nation and the world at risk.

Split Level In Jersey

April 15, 2023 By Jamie Lampidis

Everyone has limits to their goodness, Like those structures in her oil paintings, Cartoonishly stretched to contain something within.

California, Keep Your Schools Open. No Matter What

April 14, 2023 By Joe Mathews

California’s school reopening revealed education disparities, highlighting the need to rebuild trust and relationships for addressing these inequalities.

More DC author posts

Democracy Culture

Using Beer As Reminder Of UK Voting Rule Change

Using Beer As Reminder Of UK Voting Rule Change

May 7, 2023

Brixton Brewery has launched a beer can campaign to encourage voters in the UK to bring their photo ID to vote.

Macron Honors Haitian Revolutionary, But Leaves Much Unsaid

Macron Honors Haitian Revolutionary, But Leaves Much Unsaid

May 2, 2023

Macron visited the prison where Toussaint Louverture died, praising him as a hero who embodied French Revolution values.

Iranian Secret Committee 'Punished Celebrities Over Dissent'

Iranian Secret Committee ‘Punished Celebrities Over Dissent’

April 28, 2023

Iran’s Secret committee sent a list of 141 to the economy ministry, including celebrities, raising more worries over freedoms.

Rewards Get People To See Truth In Politically Unfavorable Info

Rewards Get People To See Truth In Politically Unfavorable Info

March 30, 2023

People don’t carefully evaluate links for accuracy and that partisanship may be secondary to the rush of getting a lot of likes on social media.

Pussy Riot Will Receive This Year's Woody Guthrie Prize

Pussy Riot Will Receive This Year’s Woody Guthrie Prize

March 30, 2023

Russian performance collective Pussy Riot will receive this year’s Woody Guthrie prize honoring art for social change, award organizers said Thursday.

More Democracy Culture posts