• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • AMERICAN DEMOCRACY
  • WORLD DEMOCRACY
  • POLITICAL ART
  • more
    • election technology
    • money politics
    • political dissidents
    • THIRD PARTY
      • third party central
      • green party
      • justice party
      • libertarian party
    • voting methods
  • DC INFO
    • author central
    • about
    • advertise with DC
    • contact
    • privacy policy

Democracy Chronicles

Zimbabwe’s 2008 post-vote violence has lessons for the next election

by Farai Chirimumimba - March 26, 2018

FacebookTweetLinkedInPin

Zimbabwe’s 2008 post-vote violence

This year marks 10 years since the disputed 2008 harmonized elections. At that time, the public was growing angry while it was taking more than a month for the Zimbabwe Election Commission (ZEC) to announce the result of the 29 March 2008 presidential poll. Rumor, speculation and uncertainty gripped the country. The period following that first round of the 2008 Presidential Elections in Zimbabwe was marked by political violence that left a reportedly more than 200 people dead, thousands more people injured and more than 200 000 people internally displaced – the worst violence in the southern African country since independence in 1980. Much remains to be done to prevent a repeat of the violence.

The failure to announce the result was heavily criticized by the opposition who approached the High Court for relief. However, Justice Tendai Uchena infamously ruled in favor of ZEC arguing that the law permits them to undertake a recount and verification process. Surprisingly, the ZEC alleged that they were recounting votes that they had not disclosed for any one of the candidates to ask for a recount. Had ZEC privately disclosed the result to Mugabe? If yes, than there was a calculated collusion and, if no, why then recount the votes before announcement of the result and there after maybe receive a request for recount and verification from any of the candidates?

When the polls results were finally announced on 2 May 2008, they showed that the opposition Movement for Democratic Change (MDC-T) candidate, the late Morgan Tsvangirai, had won by 47.9 percent whilst Robert Mugabe, in power since 1980, garnered 42.2 percent of the total votes. Independent candidate and former finance minister Simba Makoni pulled 8.1 percent. This effectively meant that since no candidate reached the 50 plus 1 percent vote required for outright majority, a second round was organized for 27 June 2007.

In this case the law states that the two-top candidates go for a run-off, meaning Tsvangirai and Mugabe were to square-off once more with the candidate getting the popular vote during second run winning the presidency. However, the MDC-T disputed the result arguing their tally showed Tsvangirai had won 50.3 percent of the vote, a narrow majority that would have him sworn in as the president, with Mugabe getting only 43.8 percent.

Media reports suggest that the violence after the first round began in the town of Murehwa about 70 kilometers North-East of Harare. The violence escalated throughout the country with both ZANU-PF and MDC-T blaming each other’s supporters for instigating the violence. However, western governments and most non-governmental organizations blamed ZANU-PF for the violence. Mugabe had been telling his supporters that “the bullet has replaced the ballot”.

The dispute went up a new level on 22 June, when Tsvangirai announced that he was withdrawing from the second round famously describing the run-off as a “violent sham” that was a security threat to his supporters. ZEC rejected Tsvangirai’s withdraw arguing that it was too late for him to pull out since they had printed the ballot paper with his name and all other logistics were in place.

Constitutional law expert Professor Lovemore Madhuku then said that it was politically correct for Tsvangirai to pull out because a free and fair election was not possible, yet, legally he was bound to participate: “The strict legal position is that candidature for the run-off or second election is not a voluntary exercise, you give your consent when you contest the first election.”

In other words there was no provision for withdrawal.

The dispute caught the attention of world leaders with the then United Nations Secretary-General Ban Ki-Moon on 23 June 2008 encouraging ZEC to postpone the run-off as Tsvangirai had genuine concerns that required attention. He further said that, “the people of Zimbabwe have the right to choose their leader” in a conducive environment that result in a free, fair and credible election. Then African Union Chairman weighed in describing the events unfolding in Zimbabwe as “a matter of grave concern”.

Instead of declaring Mugabe unopposed, ZEC choose to go ahead with the electoral process with Tsvangirai’s name on the ballot. Mugabe won the opposition boycotted run-off by overwhelming margin of 85.51 percent of the votes. Mugabe was hastily inaugurated at State House by then Chief Justice Godfrey Chidyausiku and on the same day travelled to Egypt for an African Union (AU) Summit where he was surprisingly welcomed.

The AU called for dialogue eventually leading to the formation of the Government of National Unity (GNU) on 13 February 2009 by ZAUNU-PF, the MDC-T and another MDC formation led by Professor Arthur Mutambara. Mugabe remained president whilst Tsvangirai became prime minister with Mutambara and Thokozani Khupe (then MDC-T party Vice-President) becoming deputy prime ministers.

Ministerial posts were shared with ZANU-PF getting the bulk at the same time retaining key portfolios that include defense, security and agriculture whilst sharing the powerful ‘Home Affairs’ portfolio which the Registrar-General then tasked with preparing the voters roll. Police also fell under a system where both ZANU-PF and MDC-T had co-ministers. MDC-T was able to wrestle control of the lucrative finance ministry and under the leadership of Tendai Biti was able to stabilize the economy.

Mugabe was later to slip on the eve of his 2013 general election whilst addressing security chiefs where he said Tsvangirai in 2008 won by 73 percent. Whether a slip of a tongue or not, it fed a widely accepted view that Tsvangirai won the 2008 presidential election and victory was stolen during the five weeks of delayed election results with the help of a questionable High Court Judgment.

The tragic lessons that can be drawn from the 2008 political violence are that such electoral fights can tear apart the social fabric of a nation and that the power to govern can only be derived from the people. Another lesson is that holding elections without ensuring strong independent institutions, like the courts, can lead to a sham democracy. Holding elections is but one element of democracy that need to be further buttressed with a vibrant parliament and protection of human rights.

Mugabe cannot argue that the elections were democratic whilst underperforming with regards to upholding human rights, supporting the oversight role of parliament, the independence of the judiciary, and other key pillars of democracy. A country’s election management body must be independent of the ruling government and must remain absolutely impartial when conducting elections with procedure clearly spelt out and dispute mechanisms in place.

Another election approaches

In July/August 2018, Zimbabwe heads for another crucial general election. And for the first time in nearly two decades the faces of Mugabe and Tsvangirai will not be on the ballot paper. Although 112 political parties have confirmed to participate, the real fight is between incumbent Emmerson Mnangagwa of ZANU-PF and Advocate Nelson Chamisa of the MDC-T.

Already there are reports of intimidation of voters. There are reports that ZANU-PF members are demanding voter registration slips from the electorate. The alleged deployment of 5,000 soldiers by President Mnangagwa’s government is seen as a strategy resembling the 2008 disputed election.

However, it is encouraging to note that Mnangagwa has invited international election observers, some whom have already visited the country for pre-election assessment. European Union election observers arrived only last week. At the same time, Mnangagwa has invited all political parties for a conference to iron out any differences.

It is only the politics of compromise that can solve political problems, not the law or technical support from donors. It remains be seen whether Mnangagwa’s overtures are cosmetic to divert political parties and observers from the obscure National Logistic Committee that is said allegedly indirectly runs the elections. As a result of the continued uncertainty, one of the key factors during the ensuing harmonized elections will be how results are processed, and their announcement managed, to avoid a repeat of 2008.

FacebookTweetLinkedInPin

Filed Under: DC Authors Tagged With: Africa, Robert Mugabe, Zimbabwe

About Farai Chirimumimba

Farai Chirimumimba is a journalist based in Zimbabwe. He researches and writes about political and security dynamics in Zimbabwe, drawing from his background in peacebuilding and conflict transformation for sustainable development. As a journalist and researcher, Farai also has special interests on knowledge of technical aspects on governance and electoral issues in Africa. He has been writing for Democracy Chronicles since early 2017. Farai is also a reporter for Spiked Online Media based in Zimbabwe.

Some highlighted Democracy Chronicles topics

Africa American Corruption American Local Elections American State Elections Asia Capitalism and Big Business Celebrity Politics China Democracy Charity Democracy Protests Democrats Dictatorships Education Election History Election Methods Election Security Election Transparency Europe Internet and Democracy Journalism and Free Speech Middle East Minority Voting Rights Money Politics New York City and State Elections Political Artwork Political Dissidents Political Lobbying Redistricting Republicans Russia Socialism and Labor Social Media and Democracy South America Spying and Privacy Supreme Court Third Party Voter Access Voter ID Voter Registration Voter Suppression Voter Turnout Voting Technology Women Voting Rights Worldwide Worldwide Corruption

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Home | DC AUTHORS | Zimbabwe’s 2008 post-vote violence has lessons for the next election

Primary Sidebar

Advertise button

Courts Off The Deep End, Again

By Andrew Straw February 1, 2023

Closing the courts, shutting down dissent, and violating the rights of whistleblowers. These are not the actions of an open, free society.

The Christian Evangelical Church

By Jack Jones January 22, 2023

I am not against Big Business having a voice, just not all the voices, and especially not an impersonator pretending to speak for God.

democracy chronicles newsletter

DC AUTHORS

No One In Monterey County Is Good Enough To Serve In Legislature

By Joe Mathews January 9, 2023

California’s “democratic reforms” have left a place as… [key] as Monterey County without any state representation from one of its own.

In America, the Joe-mocracy Rules

By Joe Mathews December 27, 2022

A republic? A democracy? No, our country is an avuncular autocracy run by old guys named joe.

Property Rights, Indiana-Style

By Andrew Straw December 24, 2022

Indiana’s justices have replaced constitutional property rights with ad hominem politics. Replacing them starts with better governors.

To The American Oligarchs: Lay Off Us

By Jack Jones December 21, 2022

No matter how many jobs are ruthlessly pulled out from under us, we are still going to do what it takes to put food on the table.

Indiana’s Irrational Ballot Access System

By Andrew Straw December 4, 2022

Opposing the potential 2024 retention of the Chief Justice Loretta Rush will be key to preventing disability discrimination bad blood in Indiana courts.

Federal Judge Strikes Down Biden’s Loan Forgiveness program

By Jack Jones November 24, 2022

What is unlawful is the Texas federal judge’s decision to strike down President Biden’s loan forgiveness program, not the program itself.

DeSantis Battles Trump in Florida Steel Cage Match

By Steve Schneider November 20, 2022

We take you now to the much-anticipated DeSantis-Trump steel cage match, in which “DeSanctimonious” has promised to “kick Trump’s ass.”

MORE FROM OUR AUTHORS

VISIT OUR POLITICAL ART SECTION:

dc political art

DEMOCRACY CULTURE

Russian Wagner Boss Acknowledges Comparison With Rasputin

Russian Wagner Boss Acknowledges Comparison With Rasputin

January 30, 2023

Russian mercenary boss Yevgeny Prigozhin responded to comparisons [with]…Rasputin who treated the son of the last tsar for haemophilia.

ChatGPT Is Changing Education, AI Experts Say

ChatGPT Is Changing Education, AI Experts Say

January 30, 2023

Newly-launched AI-powered chatbot ChatGPT is changing the internet landscape. It presents several opportunities, including in education.

Girl Scouts Earn Democracy Badge At Workshop In Salina

Girl Scouts Earn Democracy Badge At Workshop In Salina

January 26, 2023

The workshop assisted Girl Scouts in grades K–10 in earning their Democracy Badge through learning activities on democracy.

Study: Media Can Reduce Polarization By Telling Personal Stories

Study: Media Can Reduce Polarization By Telling Personal Stories

January 26, 2023

Sharing personal experiences and pairing them with facts reduces political dehumanization and increases political tolerance.

FEC Hikes Contribution Limits Ahead Of 2024 Election Cycle

Study: 2020 Election Resulted In Increased Anxiety And Depression

January 7, 2023

A review of 2020 Household Pulse Survey data reveals that as an election nears, people in [America] report more depression and anxiety.

MORE CULTURE

VISIT OUR US DEMOCRACY SECTION:

American Democracy